5 Big Names to Replace Hugo Broos After FIFA World Cup 2026 as Benni McCarthy Emerges a Strong Contender

South Africa coach Hugo Broos has already said he will end his career after leading Bafana Bafana to the 2026 FIFA World Cup in the United States, Mexico, and Canada, sparking a national debate about who should succeed him. 

Broos, who has been in charge since May 2021, is the longest-serving coach since South Africa’s readmission to international football in 1992. He has made it clear he wants his assistant, Helman Mkhalele, to take over. 

PAY ATTENTION: Follow us on Google News, Stay informed with Latest Sport News

But with Mkhalele’s lack of head coaching experience, questions are being asked whether the national team should be entrusted to a novice or whether a more seasoned hand is needed to take Bafana to the next level.

Bradley Carnell has quietly built a reputation as one of South Africa’s brightest coaching exports. After starting out as an assistant at Free State Stars and Orlando Pirates, Carnell moved to Major League Soccer (MLS), where he made an immediate impact. His work with St. Louis City in 2023 was particularly impressive, guiding the new franchise to the top of the regular-season standings in their debut campaign.

Following that, Carnell took charge of Philadelphia Union, continuing his streak of success by once again finishing at the summit of the table. His attention to detail, modern tactical approach, and ability to get the best out of players have made him a respected figure abroad. He represents a new generation of South African coaches who blend local football knowledge with international experience.

Carnell’s appointment could be a bold step toward modernization for Bafana Bafana. His overseas experience would bring a fresh tactical identity and professionalism, key qualities if South Africa aims to compete with the continent’s best. However, the question remains whether he would leave the thriving environment of the MLS for the pressure cooker of national team management.

Gavin Hunt is arguably South Africa’s most experienced domestic coach. Now in his 28th successive season in the Premier Soccer League, Hunt holds the record for the most matches coached in the country’s professional football history. His track record includes multiple league titles with SuperSport United and Bidvest Wits, built on discipline, structure, and tactical awareness.

Hunt has made no secret of his desire to coach the national team one day. In fact, he had a brief taste back in 2006 when Pitso Mosimane invited him to serve as an advisor for a World Cup qualifier against Zambia. That experience only strengthened his belief that he could one day lead Bafana Bafana on a permanent basis.

Appointing Hunt would offer stability and continuity within South African football. He understands the domestic game better than most and would likely command respect from players. However, critics may argue that his pragmatic approach is outdated in modern international football, which demands flexibility and flair.

Steve Komphela brings a blend of intelligence, leadership, and deep understanding of South African football. As a former captain of Bafana Bafana and caretaker coach of the national side, he knows what it takes to lead both on and off the pitch. His experience with youth national teams—U20 and U23—means he has worked closely with many players who now form the core of the senior team.

Komphela’s coaching résumé includes stints at Kaizer Chiefs and as an assistant at Mamelodi Sundowns, where he honed his tactical acumen under a highly competitive environment. He is well-respected for his articulate communication style and ability to motivate players.

However, despite his experience, Komphela’s critics point to his lack of major silverware as a concern. Yet his deep roots in the national structure and leadership qualities make him a compelling option to guide Bafana in a new era.

Benni McCarthy is the people’s choice for many South African fans. As the country’s all-time top scorer and the man who netted its first-ever World Cup goal, McCarthy’s credentials as a player are legendary. But he has also proven his coaching mettle. Starting with Cape Town City, he delivered attractive football and silverware, before impressing further with AmaZulu, whom he guided to a CAF Champions League spot.

Currently part of Erik ten Hag’s coaching staff at Manchester United, McCarthy has gained invaluable experience working with world-class players. His recent involvement with Kenya’s Harambee Stars as a national team coach adds international exposure to his portfolio.

McCarthy’s charisma, tactical intelligence, and connection with players could make him the perfect bridge between generations. While still young in coaching terms, his hunger, reputation, and global experience make him a dream appointment for many supporters.

No South African coach has achieved more than Pitso Mosimane. With three CAF Champions League titles and an impressive record across Africa and the Middle East, Mosimane’s name is synonymous with success. His previous stint as Bafana coach ended in disappointment in 2012, but the lessons from that experience could serve him well if given another chance.

Mosimane’s tactical nous, man-management, and ability to handle pressure make him an ideal candidate. He also understands the intricacies of international football, both technically and psychologically.

Reappointing Mosimane would bring a sense of unfinished business full circle. For a generation longing to see South Africa return to its former glory, “Jingles” might just be the man to make that happen.